Comparisons
This section compares DataFrames.jl with other data manipulation frameworks in Python, R, and Stata.
A sample data set can be created using the following code:
using DataFrames
using Statistics
df = DataFrame(grp=repeat(1:2, 3), x=6:-1:1, y=4:9, z=[3:7; missing], id='a':'f')
df2 = DataFrame(grp=[1, 3], w=[10, 11])
Some of the operations mutate the tables so every operation assumes that it is done on the original data frame.
Note that in the comparisons presented below predicates like x -> x >= 1
can be more compactly written as =>(1)
. The latter form has an additional benefit that it is compiled only once per Julia session (as opposed to x -> x >= 1
which defines a new anonymous function every time it is introduced).
Comparison with the Python package pandas
The following table compares the main functions of DataFrames.jl with the Python package pandas (version 1.1.0):
import pandas as pd
import numpy as np
df = pd.DataFrame({'grp': [1, 2, 1, 2, 1, 2],
'x': range(6, 0, -1),
'y': range(4, 10),
'z': [3, 4, 5, 6, 7, None]},
index = list('abcdef'))
df2 = pd.DataFrame({'grp': [1, 3], 'w': [10, 11]})
Because pandas supports multi-index, this example data frame is set up with a
to f
as row indices rather than a separate id
column.
Accessing data
Operation | pandas | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Cell indexing by location | df.iloc[1, 1] | df[2, 2] |
Row slicing by location | df.iloc[1:3] | df[2:3, :] |
Column slicing by location | df.iloc[:, 1:] | df[:, 2:end] |
Row indexing by label | df.loc['c'] | df[findfirst(==('c'), df.id), :] |
Column indexing by label | df.loc[:, 'x'] | df[:, :x] |
Column slicing by label | df.loc[:, ['x', 'z']] | df[:, [:x, :z]] |
df.loc[:, 'x':'z'] | df[:, Between(:x, :z)] | |
Mixed indexing | df.loc['c'][1] | df[findfirst(==('c'), df.id), 2] |
Note that Julia uses 1-based indexing, inclusive on both ends. A special keyword end
can be used to indicate the last index. Likewise, the begin
keyword can be used to indicate the first index.
In addition, when indexing a data frame with the findfirst
function, a single DataFrameRow
object is returned. In the case that id
is not unique, you can use the findall
function or boolean indexing instead. It would then return a DataFrame
object containing all matched rows. The following two lines of code are functionally equivalent:
df[findall(==('c'), df.id), :]
df[df.id .== 'c', :]
DataFrames.jl's indexing always produces a consistent and predictable return type. By contrast, pandas' loc
function returns a Series
object when there is exactly one 'c'
value in the index, and it returns a DataFrame
object when there are multiple rows having the index value of 'c'
.
Common operations
Operation | pandas | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Reduce multiple values | df['z'].mean(skipna = False) | mean(df.z) |
df['z'].mean() | mean(skipmissing(df.z)) | |
df[['z']].agg(['mean']) | combine(df, :z => mean ∘ skipmissing) | |
Add new columns | df.assign(z1 = df['z'] + 1) | transform(df, :z => (v -> v .+ 1) => :z1) |
Rename columns | df.rename(columns = {'x': 'x_new'}) | rename(df, :x => :x_new) |
Pick & transform columns | df.assign(x_mean = df['x'].mean())[['x_mean', 'y']] | select(df, :x => mean, :y) |
Sort rows | df.sort_values(by = 'x') | sort(df, :x) |
df.sort_values(by = ['grp', 'x'], ascending = [True, False]) | sort(df, [:grp, order(:x, rev = true)]) | |
Drop missing rows | df.dropna() | dropmissing(df) |
Select unique rows | df.drop_duplicates() | unique(df) |
Note that pandas skips NaN
values in its analytic functions by default. By contrast, Julia functions do not skip NaN
's. If necessary, you can filter out the NaN
's before processing, for example, mean(Iterators.filter(!isnan, x))
.
Pandas uses NaN
for representing both missing data and the floating point "not a number" value. Julia defines a special value missing
for representing missing data. DataFrames.jl respects general rules in Julia in propagating missing
values by default. If necessary, the skipmissing
function can be used to remove missing data. See the Missing Data section for more information.
In addition, pandas keeps the original column name after applying a function. DataFrames.jl appends a suffix to the column name by default. To keep it simple, the examples above do not synchronize the column names between pandas and DataFrames.jl (you can pass renamecols=false
keyword argument to select
, transform
and combine
functions to retain old column names).
Mutating operations
Operation | pandas | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Add new columns | df['z1'] = df['z'] + 1 | df.z1 = df.z .+ 1 |
transform!(df, :z => (x -> x .+ 1) => :z1) | ||
df.insert(1, 'const', 10) | insertcols!(df, 2, :const => 10) | |
Rename columns | df.rename(columns = {'x': 'x_new'}, inplace = True) | rename!(df, :x => :x_new) |
Sort rows | df.sort_values(by = 'x', inplace = True) | sort!(df, :x) |
Drop missing rows | df.dropna(inplace = True) | dropmissing!(df) |
Select unique rows | df.drop_duplicates(inplace = True) | unique!(df) |
Generally speaking, DataFrames.jl follows the Julia convention of using !
in the function name to indicate mutation behavior.
Grouping data and aggregation
DataFrames.jl provides a groupby
function to apply operations over each group independently. The result of groupby
is a GroupedDataFrame
object which may be processed using the combine
, transform
, or select
functions. The following table illustrates some common grouping and aggregation usages.
Operation | pandas | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Aggregate by groups | df.groupby('grp')['x'].mean() | combine(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean) |
Rename column after aggregation | df.groupby('grp')['x'].mean().rename("my_mean") | combine(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean => :my_mean) |
Add aggregated data as column | df.join(df.groupby('grp')['x'].mean(), on='grp', rsuffix='_mean') | transform(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean) |
...and select output columns | df.join(df.groupby('grp')['x'].mean(), on='grp', rsuffix='_mean')[['grp', 'x_mean']] | select(groupby(df, :grp), :id, :x => mean) |
Note that pandas returns a Series
object for 1-dimensional result unless reset_index
is called afterwards. The corresponding DataFrames.jl examples return an equivalent DataFrame
object. Consider the first example:
>>> df.groupby('grp')['x'].mean()
grp
1 4
2 3
Name: x, dtype: int64
For DataFrames.jl, it looks like this:
julia> combine(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean)
2×2 DataFrame
Row │ grp x_mean
│ Int64 Float64
─────┼────────────────
1 │ 1 4.0
2 │ 2 3.0
In DataFrames.jl, the GroupedDataFrame
object supports an efficient key lookup. Hence, it performs well when you need to perform lookups repeatedly.
More advanced commands
This section includes more complex examples.
Operation | pandas | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Complex Function | df[['z']].agg(lambda v: np.mean(np.cos(v))) | combine(df, :z => v -> mean(cos, skipmissing(v))) |
Aggregate multiple columns | df.agg({'x': max, 'y': min}) | combine(df, :x => maximum, :y => minimum) |
df[['x', 'y']].mean() | combine(df, [:x, :y] .=> mean) | |
df.filter(regex=("^x")).mean() | combine(df, names(df, r"^x") .=> mean) | |
Apply function over multiple variables | df.assign(x_y_cor = np.corrcoef(df.x, df.y)[0, 1]) | transform(df, [:x, :y] => cor) |
Row-wise operation | df.assign(x_y_min = df.apply(lambda v: min(v.x, v.y), axis=1)) | transform(df, [:x, :y] => ByRow(min)) |
df.assign(x_y_argmax = df.apply(lambda v: df.columns[v.argmax()], axis=1)) | transform(df, AsTable([:x, :y]) => ByRow(argmax)) | |
DataFrame as input | df.groupby('grp').head(2) | combine(d -> first(d, 2), groupby(df, :grp)) |
DataFrame as output | df[['x']].agg(lambda x: [min(x), max(x)]) | combine(df, :x => (x -> (x=[minimum(x), maximum(x)],)) => AsTable) |
Note that pandas preserves the same row order after groupby
whereas DataFrames.jl shows them grouped by the provided keys after the combine
operation, but select
and transform
retain an original row ordering.
Joining data frames
DataFrames.jl supports join operations similar to a relational database.
Operation | pandas | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Inner join | pd.merge(df, df2, how = 'inner', on = 'grp') | innerjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Outer join | pd.merge(df, df2, how = 'outer', on = 'grp') | outerjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Left join | pd.merge(df, df2, how = 'left', on = 'grp') | leftjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Right join | pd.merge(df, df2, how = 'right', on = 'grp') | rightjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Semi join (filtering) | df[df.grp.isin(df2.grp)] | semijoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Anti join (filtering) | df[~df.grp.isin(df2.grp)] | antijoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
For multi-column joins, both pandas and DataFrames.jl accept an array for the on
keyword argument.
In the cases of semi joins and anti joins, the isin
function in pandas can still be used as long as the join keys are combined in a tuple. In DataFrames.jl, it just works normally with an array of join keys specified in the on
keyword argument.
Comparison with the R package dplyr
The following table compares the main functions of DataFrames.jl with the R package dplyr (version 1):
df <- tibble(grp = rep(1:2, 3), x = 6:1, y = 4:9,
z = c(3:7, NA), id = letters[1:6])
Operation | dplyr | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Reduce multiple values | summarize(df, mean(x)) | combine(df, :x => mean) |
Add new columns | mutate(df, x_mean = mean(x)) | transform(df, :x => mean => :x_mean) |
Rename columns | rename(df, x_new = x) | rename(df, :x => :x_new) |
Pick columns | select(df, x, y) | select(df, :x, :y) |
Pick & transform columns | transmute(df, mean(x), y) | select(df, :x => mean, :y) |
Pick rows | filter(df, x >= 1) | subset(df, :x => ByRow(x -> x >= 1)) |
Sort rows | arrange(df, x) | sort(df, :x) |
As in dplyr, some of these functions can be applied to grouped data frames, in which case they operate by group:
Operation | dplyr | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Reduce multiple values | summarize(group_by(df, grp), mean(x)) | combine(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean) |
Add new columns | mutate(group_by(df, grp), mean(x)) | transform(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean) |
Pick & transform columns | transmute(group_by(df, grp), mean(x), y) | select(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean, :y) |
The table below compares more advanced commands:
Operation | dplyr | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Complex Function | summarize(df, mean(x, na.rm = T)) | combine(df, :x => x -> mean(skipmissing(x))) |
Transform several columns | summarize(df, max(x), min(y)) | combine(df, :x => maximum, :y => minimum) |
summarize(df, across(c(x, y), mean)) | combine(df, [:x, :y] .=> mean) | |
summarize(df, across(starts_with("x"), mean)) | combine(df, names(df, r"^x") .=> mean) | |
summarize(df, across(c(x, y), list(max, min))) | combine(df, ([:x, :y] .=> [maximum minimum])...) | |
Multivariate function | mutate(df, cor(x, y)) | transform(df, [:x, :y] => cor) |
Row-wise | mutate(rowwise(df), min(x, y)) | transform(df, [:x, :y] => ByRow(min)) |
mutate(rowwise(df), which.max(c_across(matches("^x")))) | transform(df, AsTable(r"^x") => ByRow(argmax)) | |
DataFrame as input | summarize(df, head(across(), 2)) | combine(d -> first(d, 2), df) |
DataFrame as output | summarize(df, tibble(value = c(min(x), max(x)))) | combine(df, :x => (x -> (value = [minimum(x), maximum(x)],)) => AsTable) |
Comparison with the R package data.table
The following table compares the main functions of DataFrames.jl with the R package data.table (version 1.14.1).
library(data.table)
df <- data.table(grp = rep(1:2, 3), x = 6:1, y = 4:9,
z = c(3:7, NA), id = letters[1:6])
df2 <- data.table(grp=c(1,3), w = c(10,11))
Operation | data.table | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Reduce multiple values | df[, .(mean(x))] | combine(df, :x => mean) |
Add new columns | df[, x_mean:=mean(x) ] | transform!(df, :x => mean => :x_mean) |
Rename column (in place) | setnames(df, "x", "x_new") | rename!(df, :x => :x_new) |
Rename multiple columns (in place) | setnames(df, c("x", "y"), c("x_new", "y_new")) | rename!(df, [:x, :y] .=> [:x_new, :y_new]) |
Pick columns as dataframe | df[, .(x, y)] | select(df, :x, :y) |
Pick column as a vector | df[, x] | df[!, :x] |
Remove columns | df[, -"x"] | select(df, Not(:x)) |
Remove columns (in place) | df[, x:=NULL] | select!(df, Not(:x)) |
Remove columns (in place) | df[, c("x", "y"):=NULL] | select!(df, Not([:x, :y])) |
Pick & transform columns | df[, .(mean(x), y)] | select(df, :x => mean, :y) |
Pick rows | df[ x >= 1 ] | filter(:x => >=(1), df) |
Sort rows (in place) | setorder(df, x) | sort!(df, :x) |
Sort rows | df[ order(x) ] | sort(df, :x) |
Grouping data and aggregation
Operation | data.table | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Reduce multiple values | df[, mean(x), by=id ] | combine(groupby(df, :id), :x => mean) |
Add new columns (in place) | df[, x_mean:=mean(x), by=id] | transform!(groupby(df, :id), :x => mean) |
Pick & transform columns | df[, .(x_mean = mean(x), y), by=id] | select(groupby(df, :id), :x => mean, :y) |
More advanced commands
Operation | data.table | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Complex Function | df[, .(mean(x, na.rm=TRUE)) ] | combine(df, :x => x -> mean(skipmissing(x))) |
Transform certain rows (in place) | df[x<=0, x:=0] | df.x[df.x .<= 0] .= 0 |
Transform several columns | df[, .(max(x), min(y)) ] | combine(df, :x => maximum, :y => minimum) |
df[, lapply(.SD, mean), .SDcols = c("x", "y") ] | combine(df, [:x, :y] .=> mean) | |
df[, lapply(.SD, mean), .SDcols = patterns("*x") ] | combine(df, names(df, r"^x") .=> mean) | |
df[, unlist(lapply(.SD, function(x) c(max=max(x), min=min(x)))), .SDcols = c("x", "y") ] | combine(df, ([:x, :y] .=> [maximum minimum])...) | |
Multivariate function | df[, .(cor(x,y)) ] | transform(df, [:x, :y] => cor) |
Row-wise | df[, min_xy := min(x, y), by = 1:nrow(df)] | transform!(df, [:x, :y] => ByRow(min)) |
df[, argmax_xy := which.max(.SD) , .SDcols = patterns("*x"), by = 1:nrow(df) ] | transform!(df, AsTable(r"^x") => ByRow(argmax)) | |
DataFrame as output | df[, .SD[1], by=grp] | combine(groupby(df, :grp), first) |
DataFrame as output | df[, .SD[which.max(x)], by=grp] | combine(groupby(df, :grp), sdf -> sdf[argmax(sdf.x), :]) |
Joining data frames
Operation | data.table | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Inner join | merge(df, df2, on = "grp") | innerjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Outer join | merge(df, df2, all = TRUE, on = "grp") | outerjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Left join | merge(df, df2, all.x = TRUE, on = "grp") | leftjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Right join | merge(df, df2, all.y = TRUE, on = "grp") | rightjoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Anti join (filtering) | df[!df2, on = "grp" ] | antijoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Semi join (filtering) | merge(df1, df2[, .(grp)]) | semijoin(df, df2, on = :grp) |
Comparison with Stata (version 8 and above)
The following table compares the main functions of DataFrames.jl with Stata:
Operation | Stata | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Reduce multiple values | collapse (mean) x | combine(df, :x => mean) |
Add new columns | egen x_mean = mean(x) | transform!(df, :x => mean => :x_mean) |
Rename columns | rename x x_new | rename!(df, :x => :x_new) |
Pick columns | keep x y | select!(df, :x, :y) |
Pick rows | keep if x >= 1 | subset!(df, :x => ByRow(x -> x >= 1)) |
Sort rows | sort x | sort!(df, :x) |
Note that the suffix !
(i.e. transform!
, select!
, etc) ensures that the operation transforms the dataframe in place, as in Stata
Some of these functions can be applied to grouped data frames, in which case they operate by group:
Operation | Stata | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Add new columns | egen x_mean = mean(x), by(grp) | transform!(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean) |
Reduce multiple values | collapse (mean) x, by(grp) | combine(groupby(df, :grp), :x => mean) |
The table below compares more advanced commands:
Operation | Stata | DataFrames.jl |
---|---|---|
Transform certain rows | replace x = 0 if x <= 0 | transform(df, :x => (x -> ifelse.(x .<= 0, 0, x)) => :x) |
Transform several columns | collapse (max) x (min) y | combine(df, :x => maximum, :y => minimum) |
collapse (mean) x y | combine(df, [:x, :y] .=> mean) | |
collapse (mean) x* | combine(df, names(df, r"^x") .=> mean) | |
collapse (max) x y (min) x y | combine(df, ([:x, :y] .=> [maximum minimum])...) | |
Multivariate function | egen z = corr(x y) | transform!(df, [:x, :y] => cor => :z) |
Row-wise | egen z = rowmin(x y) | transform!(df, [:x, :y] => ByRow(min) => :z) |